The Traitors fans want Colton Underwood banished from the castle ASAP! In fact, they never wanted him on the show in the first place, and it is all because of his scary past... Let's go back to 2018. It's Colton's season of The Bachelor, where he meets Cassie Randolph. She won, and they dated following the show. However, they broke up in May 2020 - a year before he blindsided her and came out as gay. But before dropping the news of his sexuality, the end of their relationship got very, very messy.