The Vampire Diaries alum Paul Wesley popped the question to his girlfriend of three years, Natalie Kuckenburg. "Yes ," Kuckenburg, 25, wrote via Instagram on Saturday, July 19. "Always and forever." In the snap, Kuckenburg held Wesley's hand while showing off her new, oval-shaped diamond engagement ring. Wesley, 42, and the model traveled to Italy earlier this week. Paul Wesley's Dating History: Torrey DeVitto, Natalie Kuckenburg and More "Had the best time at @belmondcastellodicasole with my love @paulwesley ," she wrote via Instagram on Wednesday, July 16.