After that cliffhanger, High Potential is back with a midseason premiere featuring even more star-studded appearances. In Us Weekly's first look at the Tuesday, January 6, episode, James Martinez plays a role in the ongoing mystery surrounding a missing painting. The heist was previously explored in an October 2025 episode where Morgan (Kaitlin Olson) and Karadec (Daniel Sunjata) tried to get to the bottom of the case - despite complications from boss Nick Wagner (Steve Howey) and art recovery specialist Rhys (Aiden Turner).