Kevin O'Leary and Timothée Chalamet's intense bare-butt paddle scene in Marty Supreme was just as crazy to film as it appeared on screen. "We had a fake paddle that had a hinge thing and a foam thing. It was supposed to not hurt. Didn't work. It broke immediately," O'Leary, 71, exclusively told Us Weekly ahead of Marty Supreme's Thursday, December 25, release. "So we got to a real paddle, wood, like, a real paddle, with grooves on the surface of it.