Kim Kardashian's legal drama All's Fair ended its first season on a shocking note with a mix of onscreen splits, lengthy sex scenes and a murder arrest. During the two-part finale, which aired on Tuesday, December 9, Carrington (Sarah Paulson) tried to secure an offer to be a partner at LVLUP Legal. Her self-sabotaging behavior created some major obstacles, starting with her affair with Allura's (Kardashian) ex-husband, Chase (Matthew Noszka). Fresh off a hookup with Allura, Chase was determined to win her back and even promised to attend therapy for sex addicts.