A spooky '90s board game is having a surprising resurgence - not because it was recently re-released, but because a group of college students got their hands on it and had a truly chilling experience... If you're reading this, be warned: blocked out memories of the terrifying game may bubble back up. Does anyone remember the '90s video board game Nightmare? It came with a VHS tape featuring a timer and an ominous narrator called The Gatekeeper who directed players through the frightening adventure.