Elizabeth Lail Photograph by Jameson Baldwin [This story contains spoilers from Five Nights at Freddy's 2.] More than a decade into her career and Elizabeth Lail is still pinching herself. The 33-year-old actress first captured audiences' attention with her role as Princess Anna in the fourth season of Once Upon a Time. She later gained more recognition with her portrayal of Guinevere Beck in Netflix's You, becoming Penn Badgley's Joe Goldberg's season one obsession who ultimately saw a tragic fate.