Coffey Anderson is in mourning after the death of his ex Criscilla Anderson. In December 2025, Netflix's Country Ever After star died at the age of 45 following a colon cancer diagnosis. "My sweet community, if you're reading this, I've finally slipped into the arms of Jesus - peacefully and surrounded by love," Criscilla wrote via Instagram at the time. "Please don't stay in the darkness of this moment. I fought hard and I loved deeply. I am not gone... I'm Home." Criscilla continued, "To my family...thank you for loving me so unconditionally.