Robert Irwin may have appeared shocked by his Dancing With the Stars season 34 win, but several Bracketology users correctly picked him to take home the trophy. At the beginning of the season, Us Weekly teamed up with Bracketology for a fantasy league where fans could predict which couple they thought would win DWTS - and 39.34 percent correctly picked Irwin, 21, as their First Impression winner. The wildlife conservationist and pro Witney Carson ultimately won the competition during the Tuesday, November 25, finale.