Last weekend, Netflix did what it does best - debuts a brand-new prestige crime-thriller show starring two of our best television actors. The Beast in Me, starring Claire Danes (Homeland) and Matthew Rhys (The Americans), is already a big hit on the popular streamer, debuting at No. 1 and hovering in the top 3 TV spots since then. The show follows Danes' Aggie Wiggs, a reclusive, grieving author who becomes wrapped up in investigating her new neighbor (Rhys), the prime suspect in his wife's disappearance. Critics are already hailing it as a compelling mystery. Read why Watch With Us agrees.