The Valley stars Jesse Lally and Michelle Saniei have differing perspectives on the day their divorce was finalized. "I will tell you, for me, the second I found out about Michelle and Aaron [Nosler], I was already done," Jesse, 43, exclusively told Us Weekly on Friday, November 15, while attending BravoCon 2025 in Las Vegas, referring to Michelle's then-boyfriend. "So, signing the actual pen to paper didn't do much for me, but I will tell you, you'll see a visceral reaction from Michelle.