Heading into November, I would have picked Stranger Things season 5 as the most anticipated Netflix show. But Netflix has a way of surprising its subscribers with unexpected blockbusters. And this month, that show appears to be The Beast in Me. It's a new mystery thriller that caught my eye when I was looking over the schedule, and I firmly believe this show is going to be a hit. So consider The Beast in Me to be Watch With Us' pick for the one Netflix show in November 2025 that you have to stream. And I'll tell you why.