Love Is Blind season 9 star Madison Maidenberg has a theory about her ex-fiancé Joe Ferrucci briefly dating fellow contestant Kacie McIntosh. "I don't know if we can call it dating, first of all," Madison, 28, said on the Wednesday, November 5, episode of the "What's the Reality?" podcast. "I think they were mutually using each other's bodies. That's what I think was going on." Madison and Joe, 29, got engaged sight unseen during Love Is Blind season 9 but didn't make it to the aisle.