Andy Cohen is not helping to end those rumors about him and John Mayer! For a long time, there has been speculation that the television personality and singer are more than friends. Andy added fuel to the rumors in 2023, telling Howard Stern that they're "in love with each other." However, the Watch What Happens Live host later insisted to The Hollywood Reporter that they "are most definitely not" hooking up despite the impression some might have gotten. The pair "love" each other but only as pals and nothing more.