As we near the final week of October, Watch With Us is excited to watch some streaming content to get us prepped for Halloween. And what's better than some real-life horror? There's one drama series in particular that we think you should squeeze in before the month's end. Devil in Disguise: John Wayne Gacy is a new show on Peacock about the titular serial killer. Starring Severance's Michael Chernus as Gacy, the show depicts the infamous murderer's double life as a respected community member and bloodthirsty killer. It's one of the scariest shows of 2025.