Posted 1 hour agoSubscribe to BuzzFeed Daily NewsletterCaret DownPeople Are Sharing The Celebs They Find "Unconventionally" Attractive, And I'm Running Out Of Room On My "Hear Me Out" Cake"I'd become a gay man for Dan Levy and I'm neither gay nor a man."by Ehis OsifoBuzzFeed ContributorFacebookPinterestLink Not too long ago, there was a trend going around where people would share the celebrities they find "unconventionally" attractive in the form of a "hear me out cake" - i.e., they'd put these celebs on sticks and put the sticks in a cake as they presented their cases. We asked the BuzzFeed Community to share some of theirs, and here are the best responses: Submissions are edited for length and clarity. 1. Taika Waititi Steve Granitz / Getty Images "Oh, I'm spilling the tea - my celeb crush is Taika Waititi! Sure, he's not your typical Hollywood heartthrob with his quirky style and dad-bod vibes, but that's what makes him so dang charming!"-modernvampire9544 2. Cate Blanchett Michael Buckner / Getty Images "Her aura is so hot."-sharptable7713 3. Paul Giamatti John Nacion / Getty Images "I swoon."-pandabear14 4. Shawn Hatosy Gilbert Flores / Getty Images "Shawn Hatosy. I loved him on The Pitt, and just watched him in Animal Kingdom. Even though he plays a psychopath, he still has this sweetness about him." -sleepingmatcha798 5. Rami Malek Visionhaus / Getty Images "Rami Malek...whewwwwwwww. I love that nerdy lil' man."-kerstonb 6. Ralph Fiennes Amy Sussman / Getty Images "At 25 or 62, he makes me so hot! And, he's a great actor."-dizzytrash392 7. Jack Black Olivia Wong / Getty Images "He's funny, talented, and kind. That's sexy to me."-jeffp16 8. Thomas Brodie-Sangster Dave Benett / Getty Images "He has a boyish charm, but with sharp features. I honestly can't put it into words. But he can be my Artful Dodger any day..."-minichef857 9. Flea Allen Berezovsky / Getty Images "Flea from Red Hot Chili Peppers. Hands down. He's even more beautiful now that he's gotten older. I would climb that man like a tree!"-karaw98 10. Dustin Hoffman Michael Loccisano / Getty Images "Dustin Hoffman was my first movie star crush."-shabooshabah 11. James Spader NBC / Getty Images "I'd hit that 'til it broke. That smoldering stare, confidence in every move...simmering unhinged-ness just below the surface...that thing he does with his tongue on his bottom lip...yes please."-shovelyjo 12. Dan Levy Sonia Recchia / Getty Images "I would become a gay man for Dan Levy. And I'm neither gay nor a man."-mosevaletservice 13. Steve Buscemi Tristan Fewings / Getty Images "Steve Buscemi can absolutely get it any day of the week."-maltesesuperb 14. Martin Freeman Hannes Magerstaedt / Getty Images "Martin Freeman got me through the pandemic as my imaginary boyfriend."-effintigre 15. Vincent Price Bob Riha Jr / Getty Images "OK. Hear me out. Vincent Price. His whole spooky, Shakespearean vibe. The voice. The cadence. The laugh. One-way ticket to Swoonsville!"-certified_drapetomaniac 16. John Leguizamo Amy Sussman / Getty Images "He's my hall pass. He has a charming sex appeal"-sportytiger677 17. John Oliver Jc Olivera / Getty Images "On Sundays, my husband is like, 'Let's watch your boyfriend.'"-oxfordcommasplz 18. Cillian Murphy Kate Green / Getty Images "Cillian Murphy has been mine since 28 Days Later. Those eyes!"-skybird0605 19. Ty Burrell Araya Doheny / Getty Images "Ty Burrell was my crush all throughout Modern Family, and he still is."-famousphone424 20. Julio Torres Bruce Glikas / Getty Images "I am hopelessly in love with Julio Torres. Something about him just makes me swoon.I feel bad even putting his name here because he's so talented, brilliant, beautiful, adorable, and hilarious, but I realize that he's not your standard, traditional hottie. That being said, he deserves all the flowers, and I would encourage anyone to check out his work!"-peacefultree81 21. Willem Defoe Deadline / Getty Images "Those eyes, that smile, his acting skills? I mean, have you seen his photos when he was young?! Heartthrob! He's double my age and could still get it."-cocothegroomer 22. Jason Mantzoukas Variety / Getty Images "Jason Mantzoukas...ZOOOOOOUKS!"-wonkish22 23. Dean Winters Jamie Mccarthy / Getty Images "Especially in SVU and Oz, but also all the time."-bulldogfan82 24. Andy Samberg Arturo Holmes / Getty Images "There's something both wholesome and naughty about him, like he'd tie you to a bed and then make you banana pancakes."-moderndaisy7711 25. Michelle Dockery Jon Kopaloff / Getty Images "She's absolutely stunning, and her voice triggers something in my brain that I think is the closest I'll ever come to ASMR."-fiercedragon227 26. Drew Carey Michael Tullberg / Getty Images "He's so funny, and I love his dry sense of humor. His intellect and humor are BIG turn-ons!"-chilllegend415 27. Sarah Jessica Parker Bravo / Getty Images "I've always thought that Sarah Jessica Parker was/is extremely beautiful. I've never seen an episode of Sex and the C
BuzzFeed Celebrity
People Are Sharing The Celebs They Find "Unconventionally" Attractive, And I'm Running Out Of Room On My "Hear Me Out" Cake
October 25, 2025
1 months ago
16 celebrities mentioned