Justin Hartley answered a burning question about whether Colter murdered someone ahead of the season 3 premiere of Tracker. Before the CBS show returned on Sunday, October 19, Hartley, 48, was asked whether his character killed the man who revealed in the season 2 finale that he killed Colter's dad, Ashton (Lee Tergesen). Hartley told The Hollywood Reporter, "I think it's safe to assume that [Otto lived]." The actor went on to hint at scenes that didn't end up airing. "I don't think it made the cut, but we did do a line where he says, 'It took everything within me not to kill him,'" he noted.