What really happened between Benson Boone and Maggie Thurmon? Oh, it's getting super messy... In case you didn't hear, news broke on September 11 that the Beautiful Things singer ended things with his girlfriend after roughly two or three years of dating. She was at his show in North Carolina on September 7. However, Benson admitted to fans during a Nashville concert that he had "a rough day" and was "very happy to be on stage." Then a couple days later the breakup news broke. The pair went on to unfollow each other on social media afterward, so fans assumed they split that day.