As you settle in under your cozy blanket to enjoy the crisper fall weather, you may find yourself wondering what to pull up from your many streaming options. This month, the Watch With Us team is recommending some underrated TV shows on Netflix that may not have lasted for many seasons but left a long-lasting impression on our hearts. Featuring actors like Jonathan Bailey and Tim Robinson, these shows are clever, creative and full of surprises. Whether you're looking for hilarious comedy or spine-chilling suspense, these hidden gems are worth adding to your October 2025 watchlist.