Michelle Saniei was faced with an ultimatum from Aaron Nosler before their relationship came to an end. After Us Weekly exclusively confirmed on Thursday, July 24, that the pair split after one year of dating, fans resurfaced a recent conversation from The Valley where Aaron, 38, expressed concerns about Michelle's estranged husband Jesse Lally. "Aaron had this conversation with me, like, 'I love you, I love Isabella. Like, I want us to one day be a family, but I can't deal with a crazy ex-husband like that,'" Michelle, 36, told Scheana Shay in a May 20 episode of The Valley.