Justin Hartley's Tracker has lost multiple cast members - but could they come back in season 3? Showrunner Elwood Reid addressed the chances of Abby McEnany and Eric Graise returning in the future, telling TV Insider on Friday, September 26, "There's a possibility [they could return], but right now, in this first block, no." Since Tracker premiered in February 2024, viewers have tuned in week after week to see Colter travel the country to help solve various missing persons cases.