When fans met Colton Underwood years ago, he was labeled the first "Virgin Bachelor." But it turns out that wasn't true! During an episode of the We Need to Talk podcast on Tuesday, the 34-year-old former football player opened up about how he navigated his sexuality before he publicly came out as gay in 2021. Colton explained that he went to great lengths to hide his secret while experimenting with men, to the point where he decided to only hook up with married guys: "I was very careful, even when I was physically experimenting with guys and trying to, like, figure myself out.