Getty Images Former Bachelor star Colton Underwood, who was long-labeled the "virgin" Bachelor, revealed he used to hook up with married men before signing on to date dozens of women on the ABC reality TV show. If you don't know, the now 34-year-old former NFL player was The Bachelor back in 2019, and he chose Cassie Randolph at the end. In 2021, he publicly came out as gay. In a new interview, Colton Underwood explained hooking up with men prior to his 2019 gig as The Bachelor "I was very careful, even when I was physically experimenting with guys and trying to, like, figure myself out.