Colton Underwood and Kaitlyn Bristow with 'Are You My First?' contestants (left to right) Rachael, Michael, Brooklyn and Layne. Disney/Jeff Share on Facebook Share on X Share to Flipboard Send an Email Show additional share options Share on LinkedIn Share on Pinterest Share on Reddit Share on Tumblr Share on Whats App Print the Article Post a Comment Logo text Are You My First? isn't Kaitlyn Bristowe or Colton Underwood's first time stepping into the spotlight of a reality television show.