Disney/Pawel Kaminski The cast of American Horror Story gathered at the Disney Upfront event on Tuesday (May 12) in New York City to reveal some exciting new casting news. However, there was a reunion on stage that has some fans talking. Evan Peters and Emma Roberts were seen standing next to one another as part of the announcement that Paul Anthony Kelly would be joining the franchise. If you don't know, Emma and Evan started dating in 2012 and got engaged in 2014. They split in 2015, but got back together and were linked until around 2019.