Getty Paul Anthony Kelly is the latest addition to the upcoming 13th season of American Horror Story. The 37-year-old actor's casting was announced during the Disney Upfront event on Tuesday (May 12) in New York City. Deadline reports that previously announced cast members Sarah Paulson, Emma Roberts, Evan Peters, Angela Bassett, Billie Lourd, and Gabourey Sidibe were all on stage when Paul "emerged from the shadows" to reveal his casting. "I guess every nightmare needs fresh blood...and thirteen's my lucky number," Paul told the audience. Paul just starred in Love Story: John F. Kennedy Jr.