The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives stars Mikayla Matthews and Taylor Frankie Paul clearly disagree on the status of their friendship. Matthews, 26, took to her Instagram Stories on Saturday, May 9, revealing in a lengthy statement that she "tried to stay as removed" as possible from Paul, 31, amid her legal drama. (Paul temporarily lost custody of son Ever, 2, after an alleged domestic violence incident with ex Dakota Mortensen. Local police declined to press charges.