Article continues below advertisementNancy Guthrie's abductor may not have been a stranger, as profilers believe the suspect most likely crossed paths with the 84-year-old before the shocking kidnapping. "[The suspect] knows in her some way," criminal profiler Dr. Ann Burgess claimed in a conversation with NewsNation's Brian Entin on Wednesday, May 6, per a news outlet. "I wouldn't think that Nancy Guthrie knew this person.