Billy Eichner is revealing where he stands with Colton Underwood after saying the reality star could be the "first gay Bachelor" before he came out. "I went on The Bachelor before we knew he was gay. As I joke, I said - because we knew he was a virgin - I said, 'You might be the first gay Bachelor and we don't even know it.' And then when he came out a few years later, that went very viral," Eichner, 47, recalled on the Monday, May 4, episode of Watch What Happens Live. "But I was just joking around.