Getty Images A scary situation has unfolded at one of the Broadway theaters in New York City's Times Square. The Eugene O'Neill Theatre, currently home to the smash hit The Book of Mormon, caught fire on Monday (May 4). The fire broke out in an electrical room on an upper floor, and has caused "substantial damage," with the building out of commission at this time. Luckily, the building was safely evacuated, but one firefighter was apparently injured. "The NYFD is at the site of the fire now and are handling matters at the Eugene O'Neill Theatre.