Ethan Plath's grand gesture of surprising ex-girlfriend Teegan Nichols in Minnesota on Welcome to Plathville appears to be backfiring. "I was just shocked seeing him. I don't know. I think just too shocked to really feel anything else," Teegan admits in Us Weekly's exclusive clip from the Tuesday, April 28, episode showing their reunion after Ethan, 27, drove to Minnesota from Georgia. "You know, [it's] nice seeing an old friend. I don't know what to say. Yeah, just shocked.