Netflix has quite a rich lineup of new and returning shows to enjoy this month, but only a few are likely to break into the streamer's top 10 chart. That's the problem with embracing quantity over quality. Sometimes, even the good shows will simply be overshadowed by the bigger hits. That's why Watch With Us is spotlighting three underrated Netflix shows you need to watch in April 2026. Our selections include a returning comedy, a remake of a classic 2000s action thriller and a true crime show that's already a blockbuster on Netflix.