TMDb/American Idol TV Carrie Underwood defends her honest judging style on American Idol, saying "I don't care" about audience boos. She and Luke Bryan discuss tough critiques. April 10, 2026 AceShowbiz - American Idol judge Carrie Underwood has openly defended the constructive criticism she delivers to contestants, even when it sparks controversy and boos from the live audience. During the April 8 episode of the "American Idol Official Podcast," host Danielle Fishel addressed the public's strong reaction to Underwood's judging style.