The search for Nancy Guthrie after her disappearance from her Arizona home brought up old feelings of grief for Nancy Grace, Wonderwall.com can reveal. During a recent appearance on the "Hang Out with Sean Hannity" podcast, the longtime legal commentator, 66, confessed that watching Savannah Guthrie's emotional interview about her mother's apparent kidnapping brought her back to the moment she found out that her fiancé had been murdered more than 40 years ago. 'There just were no words' Nancy Grace's former fiancé, Keith Griffin, was murdered in 1979.