Could we be getting a John Tucker Must Die sequel? While speaking exclusively with Wonderwall.com at Jill Zarin's Luxury Luncheon in the Hamptons, Jesse Metcalfe said fans should get ready for the beloved teen comedy to make a return. "SJWORK" / MEGA "I would obviously love to do a sequel to John Tucker Must Die," the Hollywood hunk said. "There's a script out there, which I think is pretty good. It's over at Twentieth Century Fox. But I think it could be done really well. I loved it." "I think that there's an appetite for it," Metcalfe continued of a potential followup to the 2006 hit.