Well, this is a little odd... Online searches for Nancy Guthrie's address skyrocketed just a few months before she went missing in the early morning hours of February 1. According to Google Trends data viewed by People on Thursday, there were 63 searches in Arizona for Nancy's address on December 5, 2025. Another 66 searches took place on December 10, 2025. The volume then dropped and didn't rise again until February 3, two days after she disappeared. Huh.