Scheana Shay continues to spill about her old Hollywood lovers! In her memoir, My Good Side, which dropped in July, the Vanderpump Rules alum revealed she had a long list of celebrities she hooked up with in the past - more than just Eddie Cibrian and John Mayer! But which one was "the best?" Amanda Hirsch asked the important question on Tuesday's episode of Not Skinny But Not Fat, to which Scheana responded: "Shemar [Moore].