Josh Radnor and Chelsea Handler rediscovered their history on a Thursday, January 29, "Dear Chelsea" podcast conversation. "You know, on my way over to record this podcast today, I was thinking, 'I'm interviewing Josh Radnor, and I was, like, how do I know Josh Radnor?'" Handler, 50, began the Thursday episode of her "Dear Chelsea" podcast. "Then, I was like, 'Did Josh and I ever sleep together?'" Despite Handler's hazy memories, Radnor, 51, concretely remembered his past with the comedian. "We didn't sleep together, but we made out," the How I Met Your Mother alum said.