No, Jerry O'Connell is not a homeless man, nor did he steal his own car. "Just to be clear, I am not the homeless man in this story," O'Connell, 51, shared via X on Friday, January 23, alongside a New York Post article about the recovery of his stolen Cadillac. The headline read: "Homeless man caught driving Jerry Maguire star's stolen Cadillac before he knew it was gone." O'Connell noted that he was "very grateful" for the LASD Malibu/Lost Hills Station who helped recover the car before following up with a second social media post, further attempting to clarify the situation.