Amanda Batula and Kyle Cooke's relationship issues were building for months before the pair announced their split, a source exclusively tells Us Weekly. "They were having ongoing issues all summer and decided to separate in the fall," the insider says of the Summer House costars. The source reveals that "technically" Batula, 34, and Cooke, 43, were "separated" at BravoCon 2025 that November, but "kept it under wraps." Prior to announcing their separation earlier this month, Batula "realized that Kyle's behavior was not changing," the source says.